AcreTrader review: farmland investing for accredited investors.
Farmland has delivered ~11% annualized total returns since 1990 with equity-like performance and bond-like volatility. AcreTrader is the leading platform for accessing it at retail scale. Here's what matters.
Farmland is the asset class most retail investors can't access and don't understand. AcreTrader's thesis is simple: give accredited investors direct ownership of specific US farms through an LLC structure, with the sponsor handling sourcing, due diligence, and operations. The execution is tight. The returns, over long holds, have historically justified the fees.
What AcreTrader is
AcreTrader sources US farmland (row crops like corn, soy, cotton, and permanent crops like almonds, pistachios, citrus), securitizes each farm as its own LLC under Regulation D, and sells shares to accredited investors. The farm is then leased to an operator; investors collect rental income annually and share in appreciation at eventual sale.
Returns, structurally
Farmland has two return components: cash rental yield (typically 3-5% annually) and land appreciation (typically 4-8% annually, inflation-linked). Combined long-run returns have averaged around 10-11% since 1990, per the NCREIF Farmland Index, with volatility well below equities and low correlation to stock market drawdowns.
Permanent crops (almonds, pistachios, citrus) offer higher potential returns but higher operational risk — a crop failure or a lease dispute matters more than it does on row crops.
Fees, honestly
- 0.75% annual management fee — on the farm's value
- 5% sourcing fee — built into the per-share price at closing
- Potential carried interest on sale (deal-specific; disclosed per offering)
Lower than Masterworks. Higher than Fundrise. In line with institutional farmland fund fees.
Tax treatment matters a lot here
Each farm LLC generates a Schedule K-1. The key tax feature: depreciation of farm infrastructure (irrigation, buildings, equipment) can offset rental income, meaning cash distributions often arrive with minimal current-year tax liability. This is the hidden-value feature of farmland most reviews miss.
Appreciation at sale is taxed as long-term capital gains assuming you've held 12+ months.
Liquidity: 5-10 years, period
No secondary market. Your capital is locked until the farm is sold, typically 5-10 years. This is not a product for investors who might need liquidity.
Who AcreTrader is for
- Accredited investors. Most offerings are 506(c) Reg D — accreditation required.
- Those with 10+ year horizons. Farmland rewards patience. It punishes short holds.
- Investors seeking inflation protection. Land is a classic inflation hedge, and farmland rent typically resets upward with crop prices.
- High-net-worth portfolios wanting equity-correlation diversification. Farmland has survived recessions that hammered stocks.
Verdict
4.3 out of 5. AcreTrader is the cleanest way for an accredited retail investor to access US farmland. Fees are reasonable, due diligence is credible, tax treatment is favorable. The only real caveat is the lockup, which is structural rather than a platform flaw. For long-term accredited investors wanting inflation-protected diversification, this is on the short list.
Common questions
Is AcreTrader only for accredited investors?
Most AcreTrader offerings require accreditation under Regulation D 506(c). Some deals may be available under Regulation A+ for non-accredited investors, but the primary audience is accredited.
What return does AcreTrader target?
Target returns typically range 7-13% including both cash yield and appreciation, in line with the NCREIF Farmland Index. Actual returns are deal-specific and not guaranteed.
How long is AcreTrader's lockup?
5-10 years typically. There is no secondary market. If you need liquidity before exit, you don't get it.
Does AcreTrader send K-1s?
Yes. Each farm is an LLC and issues a Schedule K-1 annually. K-1s typically arrive March-April.
How is AcreTrader different from FarmTogether?
Both offer accredited investors access to US farmland. AcreTrader has broader row-crop coverage; FarmTogether leans more into permanent crops (almonds, pistachios). AcreTrader has larger deal flow.